Joann and Steve Ward operate the service, which serves clients in all 50 states.
It really is a consumer issue worthy of our attention." said Margot Gilman, money editor for Consumer Reports.
Overall, respondents preferred free sites like Ok Cupid, Tinder and Grindr over paid sites like Match and e Harmony, in part because of the value.
The now infamous infidelity dating site Ashley Madison, which was one of the most expensive, was also the lowest-scoring online dating service, with a score of 37.
In the online dating word, there are two types of sites: those that cater to everyone regardless of sexual preference, race or religion, and the ones that instead focus on a more specific aspect so people can meet people who share the same interests and way of life.
Christian Match Maker belongs to the latter group, as their main target audience is Christians.